Base game
- True Hockey Fan Unlock all the trophies in Old Time Hockey! 2.6%Ultra rare
- We Are The Champions! Finish Story Mode on any Difficulty 10.4%Very rare
- Real Puckhead Finish one Story Mode Plus Season on any Difficulty 3.3%Ultra rare
- Pumped Up! Max out all Progression Stars before entering Playoffs in a Story Mode Season 9.1%Very rare
- Complete Set Get all the Collectibles in the Game 2.8%Ultra rare
- Teamwork In a local co-op game, score a goal while your teammate is instigating the Goaltender 6.8%Very rare
- Real Old-Fashioned Guts Win enough fights in one game to have atleast 10 opposing players fatigued 20.5%Rare
- Collateral Damage Hip Check a teammate along with an opponent 56.9%Common
- Crusin For A Boozin Hit Cliff Parnassus in the Story Game: "Cruisin for a Boozin" 55.7%Common
- Soft Sieve Instigate Guy Beaulieu in the Story Game: "Soft Sieve" 13.6%Very rare
- Eye For An Eye Injure Jim 'The Crook' Shepherd in the Story Game: "Eye For An Eye" 14%Very rare
- Ice To Meet You Win the Line Brawl in the Story Game: "Ice To Meet You" 12.7%Very rare
- Blow'em Out Win by a goal difference of 5 goals in the Story Game: "Blow'em Out" 11.7%Very rare
- Silence On The Ice Win the Bench Brawl in the Story Game: "Silence On The Ice" 13.8%Very rare
- He Shoots, He Scores Unlock the "Jack Goff" collectible by completing the Deke and Score objective in Story Mode 6.4%Very rare
- Bush League Trick Unlock the "Rex 'Goldie' Talon" collectible by completing the Bush League Trick objective in Story Mode 11.5%Very rare
- Hattrick Unlock the "Barry Walters" collectible by completing the Hattrick objective in Story Mode 5.6%Very rare
- Sacrifice The Body Unlock the "Toe O'Sullivan" collectible by completing the Block Shots objective in Story Mode 4.8%Ultra rare
- Faceoff Specialist Unlock the "Roy Sterling" collectible by completing the Faceoff objective in Story Mode 8.1%Very rare
- Penalty Killer Unlock the "Gump Monahan" collectible by completing the Kill Penalties objective in Story Mode 14.5%Very rare
- Brick Wall Unlock the "Lou Petit" collectible by completing the Shut Out objective in Story Mode 4.5%Ultra rare
- Enforcer Unlock the "Terry Peace" collectible by completing the PIMs objective in Story Mode 5.1%Very rare
- Sticky Situation Unlock the "Barney Williams" collectible by completing the Stick Fight objective in Story Mode 8.4%Very rare
Trophy facts for Old Time Hockey
How many trophies does Old Time Hockey have?
Old Time Hockey (PS4) has 23 trophies: 1 platinum, 6 gold, 12 silver and 4 bronze, worth 1,260 trophy points in total.
How hard is the Old Time Hockey platinum trophy?
2.6% of players have earned the platinum trophy in Old Time Hockey. On PlayStation's rarity scale that is “Ultra rare”.
What is the rarest trophy in Old Time Hockey?
The rarest trophy that is not secret is “True Hockey Fan” (Ultra rare), earned by 2.6% of players.
Trophy names, descriptions and rarity come from PlayStation. Guides open on their authors' own websites.